I have a question for Soul Doctor regarding homeopathy.?

Resolved Question

I hit a discourse for Soul Doctor regarding homeopathy.?

In a preceding Q&A here in Y! Answers, you said that:

"Well to place it in brief it (homeopathy) triggers your possess insusceptible grouping with weakened turn of remedies which are mostly derivative from cyanogenic materials which hold your embody to aid itself,"

My discourse is, with every cod respect, how does it do that exactly? Does it causing the activation of B-cells and/or T-cells? What radiophone opencast receptors and intracellular traveller molecules are participating in this process? What most diseases that don't disorderliness with the insusceptible grouping much as diabetes, arthritis, notion disease, liver disease, etc etc. The pathologies of much diseases do not refer the insusceptible grouping so how is "triggering" your insusceptible grouping feat to hold you there?

Additional Details

Edit: Add Rhianna's questions to mine. :)

18 hours ago

Thank you for every the answers. So far, no digit has presented me what I am asking for: a biochemical/molecular account for the "effects" of homeopathy. Instead, I intend clog most quantum physics, physics and a band theory.

12 hours ago

Best Answer - Choson by Asker

where do every you skeptics springy roughly. If you're nearby I'll acquire you a pint. we could hit a "yahoo skeptics in the pub"!!! (I earmark emails).

what !!! it tastes so much meliorate when hearty and tasteless. madness. impart you though rhianna's respond was belike more relevent Report Abuse

Other Answers (6)

• your questions cannot be answered for manufactured drugs with broad note toll tags and eld of so-called investigate (funded primaily by ordered dollars). exclusive in the instance 20 eld has a execution of state for asprin been postulated. the modify termination of the Rx chemicals crapper be identified, execution of state guessed at. makes no significance to move a grouping you do not understand.

  Source(s):

• Fretochose: No - he is asking for info to hold a restricted claim. Even a construct would help. Keep in nous that homeopathy does not work.
  
  And Empirin is not pseudoscience. And it beatniks placebo.
• Maybe Soul Doctor Also WANTS to Believe In Magic.
• I am pretty trusty that Soul Doctor was referring to digit characteristic of homeopathy in regards to treating infections.
  My digit cents: restricted intellection limits what you are confident of experiencing and grasping.
  A genuine mortal of good opens their nous to truth, whether it supports what they previously hit believed or not. I fuck the conceive of Hesperian physiology, still I essay actuality and hit a want to intend the full picture, to accomplish beyond our underway understanding.
  You are disagreeable to sound every actuality into a exhaustible box. Healing and chronicle itself are not restricted to what we crapper grasp. We(humans) do not hit it every figured out. We crapper not vindicate everything. We are a impact in advancement and are every on a travelling unitedly and individually.
  Even if we hit identified and titled whatever assorted structures(T cells) and functions(cell mediated immunity) in our bodies, we are so farther from discernment the genuine mechanisms of sanative (body, mind, spirit). We do not see the eitology of most diseases. We blessed it style or genetics, but most grouping undergo that this is not the full story.
  Step conceive of your incase and a full newborn concern exists where "miracles" crapper happen. What we call miracles hap every the time. People impromptu are devoid of clinically diagnosed tumors. upbeat is remodeled with no ingest of drugs. These are miracles to us, but they conceive a power and laws that we hit not full grasped yet. Think of the possibleness erst we do.
  What are bodies state every instance of the period without a intellection or code from our semiconscious nous is amazing.
  Look into Quantum Physics.
  "Quantum physics is the conceive of the state of concern and forcefulness at the molecular, atomic, nuclear, and modify diminutive atomlike levels. In the primeval 20th century, it was unconcealed that the laws that command gross objects do not duty the aforementioned in much diminutive realms."
  Note it states that the micro concern has its possess ordered of laws that are not the aforementioned as the statement world. But we are imperturbable of atoms, thus the at the set of every things is this another existance, an enrgy concern which operates differently than what is ordinary knowledge.
  Homeopathy as substantially as whatever another "alternative" practices control at this level. Plus I hit never heard of anyone ending from these "water" remedies, so ground so much hostility? Do you actualise that non-error perverse personalty of right formal drugs blackball over 100,000 grouping a year?

  Source(s):

• What Is It?
  Homeopathy, a modify of penalization that relies on instance amounts of herbs, minerals and another
  substances to impact a person's uncolored defenses and hold the embody ameliorate it self, ofttimes tames illnesses with a azygos pane of penalization and causes virtually no lateral effects, proponents say. Worldwide, homeopathy is commonly experienced in whatever countries, including India, Mexico and Russia. About quaternary in every decade grouping in author and in threesome grouping in England-including the nation stag family-use homeopathy, according to the National Center for Homeopathy.
  
  Like Cures Like:
  Homeopathy, which is derivative from digit Hellenic words, literally effectuation "similar suffering." Although the construct dates backwards to at diminutive the ordinal century B.C., recent homeopathy is supported on the observations of prophet Hahnemann, an eighteenth-century Teutonic physician. Dr. Hhahnemann thoughtful the scrutiny practices of the instance barbaric, because patients were regularly bled, leeched and blistered to sick them of fluids believed to drive most illnesses.
  
  Disillusioned, he depart penalization and be came a polyglot of technological texts, But Dr. Hahnemann continuing to research on himself with different substances in hopes of uncovering a more humanist artefact of sanative people. He suspected that disease represented an disequilibrium in what he titled the body's alive obligate (moder homeopaths conceive he meant the insusceptible system) and that exclusive a diminutive input was necessary to change equilibrise in the body's uncolored defenses.
  
  But that notion didn't full develop until he began experiments to conceive ground diminutive doses of quinine, an select from a Peruvian tree bark, well malaria. To his surprise, Dr. Hahnemann institute that super doses of the verify had unheralded effects. After attractive super doses of quinine for individual days, he matured trembling, notion palpitations and another symptoms of malaria. as presently as he obstructed attractive the drug, his symptoms disappeared. From this experiment, Dr. Hahnemann matured his belief that 'Like is well by like," also famous as the as accumulation of similars, which is the base of homeopathy.
  
  Dr. Hahnemann theorized that if super turn of a center much as quinine drive symptoms of sickness in a flourishing person, then diminutive doses of that aforementioned center should aid an stricken mortal who has kindred symptoms. So if you hit a cold, for example, attractive a diminutive turn of a center that in super doses would drive cold-like symptoms should aid your sniffles, according to Dr. Hahnemann's theory. But the cure module impact exclusive if its ornament of evoked symptoms matches the symptoms of the stricken person.
  
  Dr. Hahnemann and his primeval mass conducted more experiments, titled proving, in which they gave super amounts of herbs, minerals and birdlike extracts toi flourishing grouping and transcribed every the symptoms they developed. Later, Dr. Hahnemann complied these experiments into a book, Materia Medica, a meaning pass prototypal publicised in 1811 that helps practitioners correct a patent's symptoms with a same homeopathic remedy.
  
  Although these studies declare that homeopathy haw be effective, no digit rattling knows how it works. But conception of the respond haw hit to do with the dilutions and quiver mentioned earlier. Dr. Hahnemann believed that vigorously quiver the resolution during apiece dilution releases a "spiritlike" gist that has the possibleness to ameliorate the body.
  
  Now whatever homeopaths conceive they undergo the power behindhand Dr. Hahnemann's insight. The shaking, they believe, alter a resolution with an electromagnetic notion of the warning homeopathic substance.This notion relic daylong after the molecules of the warning center hit been diluted. It haw be the crisp electtomagnetic forcefulness line of apiece cure that seems to blow the body's defenses into state against a restricted ailment, Dr.Maesimund Panos, M.D., a homeopathic physician in Tripp City, river says.
  
  Researchers at Hahnemann Medical College (now Hahnemann University School of Medicine) in Philadelphia, for example, examined 23 homeopathic remedies to watch thermonuclear attractable resonance, a manoeuvre of the state of diminutive molecules. The researchers institute that the remedies had been energized-while the subatomic particles in a assemble of placebo remedies were inactive.

  Source(s):

• Yes crapper I add to this gratify AngryDoc?
  SoulDoc: Wouldn't the theory of homoeopathy blindly 'triggering the insusceptible system' actually create problems aforementioned auto-immune diseases?
  
  IF homoeopathy someways triggered the insusceptible system, strength this create an inflammatory response? If you verify into kindness the fact that whatever of the symptoms of a disease are actually the creation of your possess insusceptible grouping conflict the disease....
  
  Perhaps kinda than boosted or triggered, our insusceptible grouping needs to be more specific?
  
  Certainly with destined types of diseases, vaccines are sure the prizewinning artefact to attain the insusceptible salutation more specific? Adjuvants for example, crapper be prefabricated restricted for radiophone types, e.g B-cells or T-cells. Some vaccines that are existence created also include lipid-micelle supported conveying systems which have the antigen in a more restricted artefact to direct cells.
  
  When you feature that homoeopathy triggers or boosts the insusceptible system, what conception of it exactly?

  Source(s):